CRU-Report: CBAM threatens European aluminum production
A new report for the European aluminium industry by the independent commodity analyst CRU highlights the negative impacts of a wrongly designed Carbon Border Adjustment Measure (CBAM).
The study shows that European aluminium smelters will become cost uncompetitive if the CBAM covers indirect emissions and existing carbon leakage measures are removed. The report also anticipates costs for aluminium production will rise by 24 % to 31 % and provides insights into the complexities of designing a circumvention-proof CBAM Regulation.
Impact of the CBAM on primary aluminium
The study “Assessment of European Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism Regulation”, conducted by business intelligence analysts CRU international on behalf of European Aluminium, models the impact of the CBAM on primary aluminium and selected downstream products under different scenarios, including the phase-in of indirect emissions in the CBAM and the phase-out of EU carbon leakage measures. Given the unique challenges aluminium faces as an electricity-intensive industry, the report highlights that it is crucial for the CBAM to be initially tested only on direct emissions, as originally intended by the European Commission. “
European aluminum producers are at a disadvantage
“Our study reveals that under the current CBAM proposal, fossil fuel-based aluminium producers in third countries will pay less indirect carbon costs than European producers using decarbonised power because of the EU’s unique electricity market design. That’s why the inclusion of indirect emissions in a CBAM will not necessarily improve the competitiveness of European smelters. We also quantified and modelled the significant expected cost increases down the value chain for the most used aluminium semi-finished products,” said Zaid Aljanabi, Head of Aluminium at CRU consulting.
European smelters will lose competitiveness
The study shows that European producers’ higher indirect carbon costs under the Emissions Trading System (ETS) mean primary aluminum imports for semi-fabrication could increase up to 43 % and total value add loss of up to 77 % in the event a large share of EU production is replaced. Furthermore, if indirect emissions are included in the CBAM and carbon leakage measures are fully phased out, European smelters will lose competitiveness as they will continue to face higher indirect carbon costs than importers due to the EU ETS. All this is in the context of a historic production loss of over 900,000 t in 2021-2022.
According to the study, the current CBAM proposal can further unlevel the playing field between European and nonEuropean aluminium producers. Besides higher carbon costs for European companies, the study also points to high circumvention risks and the challenges of implementing the CBAM for the highly complex aluminium value chain. “
EA: “CBAM will have a destructive impact on the European aluminium value chain”
The proposed amendments in the European Parliament to accelerate the inclusion of indirect emissions in the CBAM will have a destructive impact on the European aluminium value chain,” warned Paul Voss, Director General of European Aluminium.
“While such initiatives are undoubtedly well-intentioned, their practical effect would be hugely damaging. The CBAM must be first tested and carefully reviewed before the inclusion of indirect emissions is considered. Ideally, this should be envisaged after 2030, when the European power grid is sufficiently decarbonised. Until then, we need to preserve, where applicable, existing national ETS compensation schemes, reinforce anti-circumvention measures to protect our competitiveness, and understand the real impact the CBAM has on downstream industries.”
Titled ‘Scaling Circularity’, Novelis‘ report on sustainability reviews metrics and success stories from the 2023 fiscal year.
At Euroguss 2024, Plasmatreat will demonstrate how metals and alloys can be optimally prepared for subsequent processes. A highlight is the Anti-Corr coating.
The EU has decided to extend until 31 March 2025 the suspension of its rebalancing tariffs on US products in the context of the steel and aluminium dispute.